Brie en Croute with Mushroom and Sundried Tomato

I love to eat.  I don’t consider eating to be just a necessary function of life, I consider it to be an integral part of my way of being.  I love to feed other people and bring them gastronomic pleasure as well as a full tummy.  I like that food, cooked in certain ways, can elicit an emotional response, a physical reaction, and an intellectual dialogue.  Plain and simple, I LOVE FOOD.  

Because I love food so much, I end up spending a lot of time playing around in the kitchen.  Sometimes this is my stress relief, other times it’s an outlet for creativity. I’ve learned that I absolutely adore, with an embarrassing delight, milk chocolate with hot mustard. I’ve learned that I despise, despite much effort, roasted red peppers with anything (that I still use them in my cooking speaks only to the fact that I love my friends, and if they love roasted peppers than roasted peppers they shall have). But creativity has a time and a place.  Sometimes you want to push your peeps a bit and serve them 7 spice roasted chicken with za’atar carrots and black radish confit in a buttered mirin reduction.  Other times you say that’s a whole lot of bullsh*t, and you just want to make people food that they’ll enjoy.  It’s not about pushing boundaries or trying creative new things, sometimes you just want to make something that looks nice enough and tastes good.  

There shouldn’t be any shame in that.  Particularly when you’re cooking for other people, what’s the point of putting in the effort if they won’t enjoy it?  Is it a successful meal because you’ve challenged their boundaries?  Because you’ve pushed them to think about different flavor combinations and cooking techniques?  Is frog leg pizza with anchovy sorbet really a victory? Or is it a successful meal because you have licked plates, smacked lips, and a satiated audience to show for your effort?

Brie en Croute is slightly passe.  Okay, more than slightly.  As soon as it becomes pub grub you know that a dish’s day in the sun has come to an end.  Nobody cutting edge wants to make Brie appetizers anymore, unless it’s covered in panko or seared in duck fat.  But here’s the way that I look at it:  it’s yummy.  Yes, I said ‘yummy’. Whatever.  At least I didn’t say ‘yumm-o’, if you know what I mean. People like it.  I can serve starters of Thai curried deviled eggs and candied sea bass fritters out the wazoo, and even though they’re delicious, it’s the breaded Brie which will be gone at the end of the night.  So here we go – I’ll raise a glass to an outdated appetizer which is past it’s prime. And I will continue to make it again, and again, and again. Why?  Because people eat it.  And they like it. And if it makes them happy, then I’m happy – ’nuff said.

Brie en Croute With Mushroom and Sundried Tomato

  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • 2 cloves of garlic
  • 8 medium-large white mushrooms (to yield about 1 cup chopped) *
  • 1/4 cup oil packed sundried tomatoes **
  • 1 tsp dried basil 
  • 500 g round of Brie cheese
  • 1 portion puff pastry
  • salt and lots of pepper
*  Button mushroom are a cop-out because I only had $12.64 on me at the time, and the Brie took up the lion’s share of that.  Meaty mushrooms like cremini/portabella would be superb, as would any number of wild mushrooms.  

** Sundried cherry tomatoes are perfect here because they don’t need to be cut up.  They’re also really easy to make (these are homemade) by cutting each tomato in half lengthwise and drying them cut side up in a food dehydrator until they’re leathery.  Packed in oil, they will keep for upwards of a year.

Chop the mushrooms into manageable pieces, approximately 1/4 inch wide and 1/2 inch long…or whatever suits your fancy. Give the garlic a nice go over with your knife until it knows who’s boss.

Heat the olive oil up in a pan over medium low heat, and gently start to sweat the garlic and onions together. ‘Sweating’, in this sense, means cooking at a lower temperature for a bit longer, and allowing your pan’s contents to slowly relax and let their juices flow without any fear of burning them. Mushrooms put out a surprising amount of liquid, so it’s best to do this without a cover on the pan.  When the mushrooms and onions are sweaty and slick, add in the oregano and give it a stir.   Salt and pepper them to taste at this point.  Mushrooms really appreciate a bit of salt.  They also have a strong affinity to freshly ground pepper.  Just sayin’…..

Chop the sundried tomatoes up into relatively bitty sized strips or pieces, or use sundried cherry tomatoes like I have here. Pour them right in, and if there’s a bit of extra oil keeping them lubed up that is abslotely okay.  Let that all cook together for another five minutes or so until you feel confident that the flavors have combined.

Take the mushrooms off the heat and allow them to cool for at least 15 minutes before you start the next step.  If you need to chill them, go nuts.  The point is that we don’t want them warm or they’ll start to melt the Brie as well as the butter in your puff pastry – and that would be tragic.  There is no melting allowed until we’re good and ready for it.

Lightly flour your work surface and begin to roll out the dough until it is between 1/4 and 1/8 inch thick. Or, as I like to say, “roll it thinly-like”.  

Store bought puff pastry is a god send, in my opinion.  I don’t have the heart to make it from scratch, but I use it all the time.  So puffy!  So buttery!  So delicious!  Such fast pastry shells!  Oh, it’s truly a joy to behold. I’ve also found that Tenderflake sells pre-rolled puff pastry which only needs a quick thinning once over. I’m genetically predisposed to abhor Pillsbury products, but puff pastry totally keeps my ships at sea.

Alright, now for the fun part.  Place the Brie smack down in the center of the pastry.   Pile the mushroom mixture on top.

Begin to fold the pastry up on top in pleats, gently pressing and holding as you go…..

…until you have a lovely little satchel of delights which is totally ensconced in it’s wondrous shroud of puff pastry, just waiting to be cooked.

Place this upside down and slide it onto a plate or tray covered in parchment paper.  Tuck it in the freezer until you’re ready to cook it up.  The parchment paper is pretty key here, because otherwise it will stick to it’s receptacle and you’ll have to heat it slightly to get it off.  Sadly, I know this from experience.  

Preheat the oven to 400F.  If you made this the day (or week) before, there is a good likelihood that it’s rock solid at this point.  That’s okay.  I find that puff pastry cooks better from a frozen state anyway for some reason.  Turn the breaded round right side up (so the pleats are on top) and place it – still on the parchment paper – onto a baking sheet.

Bake the Brie for about 15 – 20 minutes, or until it’s lightly browned on top.  

Now this is important!!  If you just tucked the Brie in the freezer for half an hour or so as you went about your business, it’s fully cooked and gently gooing up inside at this point.  If you froze it for a period of hours or days, despite the fact that it looks done on the outside, it’s probably still frozen on the inside. And after all, it’s what’s inside that counts (oh god, I’m such a hippie waiting to happen).  Turn the heat on your oven down to 250F and let it cook for an additional 10 minutes.  The pastry won’t brown any more, but the radiant heat will melt the Brie into the ooey-gooey-delightful-mess that we covet.

Final very important note!!  After taking this out of the oven please let it sit for 10 minutes before cutting into it.  When Brie melts, it melts FAST.  If you cut it too soon you’ll have a very delicious but very messy pool of cheesy lava streaming out all over the place. Letting it sit at room temperature for 10 – 15 minutes before cutting into it allows the cheese to de-liquify.  A bit of ooze is alright, but streaming cheese soup is not as attractive.

Unless you’re really greedy, of course, and in that case just go for it.  However, when you burn your chin by dripping napalm cheese all over the place, it will be your own fault.  And I will tell you this, guest or not.

So there you go.  Judge me if you want.  I serve my guests passe appetizers that are not at all cool or novel within the foodie community.  I serve them things that have been done, again and again, and are now (sadly) completely overlooked and discarded by any burgeoning chef worth his Himalayan pink sea salt.  

BUT.  I bet you $5 there won’t be any leftovers……

  • gammypie

    Oh my! This looks to die for. I’m going to make this for the family’s next Sunday dinner. Awesome recipe. Thanks!

  • Tina

    Thank you Gammpie! It’s a pretty simple and classic pairing, but always delicious. I hope you enjoy!!!

  • Margie

    I totally agree with your food/cooking philosophy here. We have a lot of lunches at work where we all bring in dishes. I never bring what I would want. I bring what people like. What’s the point of overwhelming a group of people who eat simple fare with something exotic that will frankly intimidate them. You’re smart to serve what you know people will like. I’d eat that brie all night long. Who cares if it’s fashionable or chic?! It’s good and everyone knows it!

  • Kristie

    That’s so true. Hand-rolled sushi, duck breast with leek confit, crostini with arugula and parmesan–those will get you compliments. But hearty, cheddar-y mac and cheese with breadcrumbs on top and a glass of milk? That will get you laid. And after it gets you laid, he’ll go put on an old, squishy college sweatshirt and put his arms around you and smell your hair because you’re sweet and comfortable, just like the food you made him.

  • noble pig

    That oozing brie is something I dream about…WOW!

  • Tina

    Margie – you totally know what I’m saying!

    Kristie – I met Mike’s work friends for the first time last Friday. We were chatting away, and within half an hour he’s going on to them about how I’m so great because I make the best homemade mac’n’cheese ever….maybe there IS something to be said for that!!!

    Noble Pig – I actually DID have cheese dreams the other night. Two of them. And one where I was drinking gravy. This is either guilt over the fact that I’ve been gaining weight lately, or memories of this cheese and Thanksgiving dinner…..hard to say.

  • Susan

    I don’t think I have ever wanted something more in my life. It is not even a question of my wanting this Brie en Croute With Mushroom and Sundried Tomato, I need this. I don’t know when I will make it, but I will someday and I now have something to look forward to.

  • Tina

    Susan, you would love it. I guarantee. I actually thought of you while I was making (and eating) it because it’s such a ‘you’ recipe!!!

  • Ivy

    I’ve never tried brie before but it looks delicious and sounds like an easy recipe plus I love mushrooms so I am sure I would like to try this.

  • Mike

    Ivy, I’m a total cheese wuss — seriously, I am still adjusting to anything that doesn’t start with a “chedd” and end with an “ar” — and even i got into this big-time. The brie and mushroom blend perfectly, and the pastry tempers all those big flavors into a wonderful crisp package.

  • Peter

    Tina, who cares if it’s passe or found at a pub. Home cooked is always best, never a fad and never, ever are there leftovers.

    I’m also fan of brie baked in it’s wooden container..

  • Tina

    Ivy and Peter, thanks for making me feel a bit better about this! And you’re right, there is a reason that we make these things again and again, isn’t there?